Petition 620, Petition 609, and the Road Ahead

Posted By: Laurie Weber Blog, ISFA News ,

Petition 620, Petition 609, and the Road Ahead

Dear Fabricators, Members, and Partners,

In October the California Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board granted Petition No. 620, ISFA's petition for fabrication shop licensing and a Verified Compliance Pathway. This week the Board posted it publicly. This is a milestone for every countertop and surface fabrication shop in the US.

Let me be clear about what it is not. Petition 620 does not erase or replace the process already under way on Petition No. 609. It was never meant to. Both now move forward side by side, and you will hear a lot of noise about what that means. This letter is my attempt to cut through it.

Key takeaways

  • Petition 620 and Petition 609 are two separate tracks. 609 asks whether engineered stone fabrication should be banned. 620 asks how to make sure shops are following the law. One does not cancel the other.
  • Petition 609 asked for expedited rulemaking, not an emergency standard. The Board chose the emergency route, going beyond what its own staff recommended, with known gaps in the record.
  • California has confirmed nearly 700 cases of engineered stone silicosis. No case of silicosis is acceptable. Silicosis has also always been preventable, whatever the material, and people have died of it without ever touching engineered stone.
  • An emergency rule moves fast. Once Cal/OSHA files with the Office of Administrative Law (OAL), the public has 5 calendar days to comment and OAL has 10 calendar days to decide.
  • Enforcement is the gap. Cal/OSHA inspected about 10% of California's estimated 1,342 fabrication operations from December 2023 to February 2026. A ban does not fix that gap.
  • No regulator reaches the no-employee model. Cal/OSHA and federal OSHA cover employers. The worker with no employees, and much of the 1099 workforce, sit outside that reach.
  • This will be a long process, and so far it lands on fabrication shops. The compliant shops that invested to meet the law carry the cost of every new rule.
  • Words and structure matter. ISFA is a 501(c)(6) nonprofit. We report publicly, and we have no stake in which material wins market share.

Two petitions, two different questions

Petition 609 asks whether engineered stone above 1% silica should be fabricated in California at all. Petition 620 asks how California can confirm that shops follow the silica law already on the books.

 

Petition No. 609

Petition No. 620

Filed by

Western Occupational and Environmental Medical Association (WOEMA)

International Surface Fabricators Association (ISFA)

What it asks

Expedited rulemaking to prohibit fabrication and installation of engineered stone above 1% crystalline silica

A new Section 5204.2: shop licensing, independent third-party compliance audits, exposure-monitoring reports to Cal/OSHA, and loss of eligibility when a shop falls out of compliance

Focus

The material

The shop and the worker

Effect on Section 5204

Amends the existing silica standard

Stands alongside Section 5204 and does not amend it

Status

Granted in part on May 21, 2026; Cal/OSHA is drafting the emergency rule

Granted in October 2026; posted this week; the Board must vote by March 27, 2027

A ban answers the question of which slab is allowed in the shop. It does not answer whether the shop has water on the saw, a working dust collector, a respirator program and exposure monitoring. Those are the controls that prevent silicosis with any material, and they are what Petition 620 is built to verify.

Petition 620 · Petition 609 background

Did we all misread the word "emergency"?

I'll ask the question many of you have asked me. Petition 609 did not ask for an emergency standard. In its own words, it asked the Board "to initiate expedited rulemaking to implement revisions to § 5204." The petition calls the rise in cases "a health emergency," but its request is for expedited rulemaking, which is not the same thing as an emergency regulation.

The difference matters. Expedited rulemaking still runs through the regular process: full public comment, an economic analysis, and a record built over time. Emergency rulemaking skips most of that. It is the 5-day comment window and 10-day OAL review described below.

The Board's own staff did not recommend the emergency route either. They recommended granting Petition 609 only "to the extent that Cal/OSHA is requested to convene an advisory committee." The Board went further. It granted the petition "to the extent the Board requests Cal/OSHA draft emergency rulemaking," with advisory committees running at the same time.

Did the Board have everything it needed?

I ask this with respect for the Board and the people who serve on it. The record they decided on had open gaps, and their own staff named some of them:

  • Economic impact. On the claim that a ban would have little effect on jobs, staff wrote: "Economic analysis is needed for this statement." The adopted decision does not address economic impact or feasibility.
  • Alternative materials. Staff noted the data is "more limited" on the toxicity of alternative stone, the very products shops would be asked to switch to.
  • Australia. Staff described the information on Australia's ban as "secondhand accounts" from the petitioner and other public health experts.
  • The science. The science committee the Board is forming has not yet reported.

None of this means the Board acted in bad faith. It does mean these are fair questions, and OAL is the next place they will be asked. When the emergency package is filed, OAL must decide whether the record actually shows an emergency.

Petition 609 · Board staff evaluation · Cal/OSHA evaluation · Adopted decision

How emergency rulemaking works, and who OAL is

An emergency rule can go from adoption to enforceable law in about three weeks. This is the sequence the Department of Industrial Relations presented to the Board this week:

  1. Finding of emergency. The agency documents why the rule cannot wait for the normal process.
  2. Advance notice. The agency notifies OAL and stakeholders and posts the proposal online 5 working days before filing.
  3. Submission to OAL. The official package goes to the Office of Administrative Law.
  4. Public comment. Stakeholders have just 5 calendar days to send written comments to OAL and the agency at the same time.
  5. OAL decision. OAL has 10 calendar days to approve or reject the rule.
  6. Filing and effect. Once filed with the Secretary of State, the rule is in effect for 180 days, with up to two 90-day extensions.
  7. Permanent rule. The agency must file a certificate of compliance and complete regular rulemaking to keep the rule in place.

OAL is a small, independent state office of about 26 positions, led by Director Kenneth J. Pogue. Its attorneys do not decide whether a policy is wise or whether the science is right. They decide whether the rule meets the legal standards of the Administrative Procedure Act: necessity, authority, clarity, consistency, reference and nonduplication. For an emergency rule they also decide whether the agency has actually shown an emergency.

That is why the 5-day comment window matters. Comments to OAL should speak to those legal standards, not to which product is safer. ISFA will post the filing date and our comment the day the advance notice appears.

The numbers, and the questions they raise

Yes, we can say nearly 700 California workers have engineered stone silicosis. Each case is a person. The California Department of Public Health had confirmed 644 cases as of September 16, 2026, with at least 35 deaths and 75 lung transplants, and later reporting puts the count at 668. CDPH itself says the true number is higher, because silicosis is underdiagnosed.

We know no case of silicosis is good. We also know silicosis is not new and not limited to one material. In CDPH's 2019–2024 surveillance, 53 of the 296 confirmed cases came from silica exposures other than engineered stone. Workers have died of silicosis without ever touching engineered stone. What has always prevented it is the same everywhere: control the dust.

The harder question is the workforce. CDPH has identified more than 1,300 countertop fabrication operations in California, most of them small, with a median of five workers. That suggests at least 6,500 people work in California shops today. But no agency has published how many people worked in Los Angeles, Orange and San Diego counties during the 2015–2023 demand boom, when CDPH says engineered stone demand rose 600%. Without that number, no one can say what share of that workforce is sick or where the risk really sits. ISFA has asked the state to produce it.

Then there is enforcement. From December 2023 to February 2026, Cal/OSHA inspected 135 of an estimated 1,342 operations, about 10%. Of 127 closed inspections, 120 shops were cited and 25 received Orders Prohibiting Use. If the state could not reach 90% of shops under the current standard, how will it monitor a ban? That is not a jab at an understaffed government. It is the honest question any request to regulators has to answer.

And what were those citations for? The public record does not tell us. Cal/OSHA reports how many shops were cited, but not which requirements they violated. When the health department looked at 62 of the 145 inspections through April 2026, 77% of employers were cited for at least one violation of the silica standard. That suggests some of the citations in the larger count were for things other than silica. A missing written program and dry cutting with no water are both violations, but they are not the same risk to a worker. Before California bans a material over a compliance record, fabricators deserve to see what that record actually says. ISFA will ask for the breakdown.

Who carries the weight

Every proposal on the table so far lands on the same people: the fabrication shop.

In Washington, H.R. 5437, the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Stone Slab Products Act, passed the House Judiciary Committee 16–7 in June. A Senate version, S. 4792, was introduced by Senator Ashley Moody on June 16, 2026, and referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee. These bills would block civil suits against slab manufacturers and sellers and push liability down to the shop. Did you know these bills are not limited to engineered stone? They cover stone slab products of every kind, natural and engineered alike. ISFA does not support H.R. 5437. It protects one part of the supply chain and does nothing for the sick worker.

 

In California, a ban would shut down the shops that bought the dust controls, trained their people and passed their inspections, along with the ones that did not.

Neither approach reaches the part of the industry that worries me most. Cal/OSHA and federal OSHA cover employers. A one-person operation with no employees falls outside their reach, and many installers work under exactly that model. The federal rule on who can be treated as a 1099 independent contractor is also in limbo: the Department of Labor proposed rescinding the 2024 rule in February, and shops are still waiting to see where it lands.

When the rules do not reach the person doing the cutting, the shops that follow the law are left to compete with those that do not. Licensing the shop and auditing the work is how you close that gap.

What happens next

I cannot predict the future. I can tell you this will be a long battle, and that the emergency rule still has a long way to go. Before it becomes law there is more public comment: when the Board votes, and again in the 5-day window at OAL. Even then it is temporary. Making it permanent requires regular rulemaking, with a full 45-day comment period and an economic analysis.

ISFA will respond at every one of those steps. At the same time, we will keep working on licensing. Two things can be true and happen at once: we can challenge a rushed process and build a better one in the same week.

  • Petition 609: Cal/OSHA finishes its emergency rule. The Board votes on it, the 5-day advance notice goes out, and the package moves to OAL on the timeline above. Even if it is approved, it is a temporary rule that must go through regular rulemaking to become permanent.
  • Petition 620: The Board must vote on Petition 620 by March 27, 2027. ISFA's second 45-day public comment period on our petition language opens after we repost it later this month.
  • ISFA: We will file a comment at every stage, keep training workers every week in English and Spanish, and keep building the independent audit program for California shops.

What you will likely hear after this week's meeting

  • "California banned engineered stone." Not yet. A Board vote is one step. OAL review and a permanent rulemaking still follow.
  • "ISFA's petition means the ban is off." No. The two petitions run side by side.
  • "ISFA is picking a side on materials." No. We are focused on controls that protect workers with every material.
  • "Licensing is a stall tactic." Licensing and audits are how a regulator verifies compliance at 1,342 shops with the staff it has today.

What it means for the rest of the country

What California does, other states study. Public health officials have already said they expect other states to follow California's lead. If the only model in front of them is a ban, that is what spreads. If a working licensing and audit model is in front of them too, they have a choice. That is why this work matters to every shop in every state, not only in California.

Better than yesterday

We cannot erase the past to start something new. Engineered stone has a hard history in California, and we will not pretend otherwise. We can learn from it and be better than yesterday.

The shops that follow the law have earned a path that recognizes that work. Petition 620 is that path. Stand with us, comment when the window opens, and call three fabricators you know.

Call ISFA at (888) 599-4732. Make sure your membership is current or donate to our advocacy and lobbying work in California and in Washington. That work includes fighting H.R. 5437 and S. 4792, and building a plan to compensate sick workers from our shops, no matter the material.

Dues and contributions to ISFA, a 501(c)(6), are not deductible as charitable contributions. The portion used for lobbying is not deductible as a business expense.

Laurie Weber, CEO, ISFA

P.S. Words matter

Just because a group says it is an association with members, do you know what that means?

ISFA is a 501(c)(6) nonprofit trade association. We file a public Form 990 every year. Our board serves the industry, not a single company's balance sheet. Our members approve the standards we follow, which is why our petition uses the ISO term engineered stone. We have no stake in which material wins market share. Our job is the shop and the worker.

Some groups in this debate are for-profit companies or are funded by companies with a product to protect. Their owners keep the profits, and they do not file nonprofit returns or answer to members the same way. That does not make them wrong. It does mean they are not built for the same kind of accountability.

Definitions shape what we believe. If we have heard one phrase a hundred times, it starts to sound like fact. I ask every fabricator to look at who is speaking, how they are structured, and what they stand to gain, and to ask the same of ISFA.

 

Sources